“Yoga is just stretching.”
“Buddhism is just a philosophy.”
“Eastern traditions are ways of life, not real religions.”
These are statements many of us have heard, and perhaps even believed at some point. But these perspectives are not only inaccurate, they are also rooted in Western-centric assumptions about what constitutes a "real religion."
The truth is, systems like Yoga, Buddhism, Taoism, and other Eastern spiritual practices are not "just philosophies" — they are religions in their own right. They have sacred texts, moral frameworks, rituals, and pathways to spiritual transformation. So, how did they become reduced to "philosophies" in Western discourse, and why does this distinction matter?
The Western Definition of Religion: A Narrow Box
To understand why Yoga and other Eastern systems are dismissed as "philosophies," we have to look at how the West defines religion. The Western idea of religion is often influenced by Christianity and other Abrahamic faiths. For something to "count" as a religion in this framework, it must have:
- A central deity or god figure,
- A codified set of scriptures,
- Formal worship practices (like weekly services), and
- A clear line between the sacred and the secular.
Hinduism, Buddhism, and Taoism often don't fit neatly into this box. For instance, Buddhism doesn't revolve around a singular god, and yoga isn't necessarily practiced in a temple or church. But this doesn't mean they aren't religious systems. They have all the elements of religion — just in different forms.
Hinduism, for example, considers yoga a spiritual discipline to achieve union with the divine (Brahman). Yoga isn't just about physical postures (asana) but also about breath control (pranayama), moral observances (yamas and niyamas), meditation (dhyana), and ultimately, self-liberation (moksha). These are deeply spiritual goals. Similarly, Buddhism offers an Eightfold Path — a guide for living that includes moral conduct, mindfulness, and wisdom, all leading to enlightenment (nirvana).
Western frameworks, however, often overlook these elements because they don't resemble the structure of Christianity or other "familiar" religions. As a result, practices like meditation, yoga, and mindfulness are extracted from their spiritual roots and marketed as wellness trends.
The Impact of Western Reductionism: From Sacred to Secular
Why did the West feel the need to strip the "religion" label from these Eastern traditions? Part of it comes down to colonization, Orientalism, and cultural commodification. When colonizers encountered Eastern systems, they couldn't (or wouldn't) recognize them as "proper" religions. They categorized them as "philosophies" or "primitive spiritual systems" to maintain a perceived cultural superiority.
This reductionism continues today in the modern wellness industry. Yoga is packaged as fitness, not faith. Meditation is seen as a mental health tool, not a religious practice. Buddhism is praised for its "life advice," but its deeper spiritual truths are glossed over. This shift allows Western audiences to consume these practices without engaging with their cultural or religious roots. It makes it easier to "adopt" yoga without reflecting on Hinduism, or practice meditation without acknowledging Buddhism.
This is why you’ll see meditation apps offering "mindfulness exercises" with zero mention of Buddhism, despite the fact that mindfulness (or sati) is a core Buddhist practice. Similarly, yoga classes emphasize “mind-body connection” but rarely teach the Eight Limbs of Yoga, which include ethical precepts like non-violence (ahimsa) and truthfulness (satya).
By stripping these practices of their religious elements, the West can sell them as trendy self-improvement tools. But this also strips them of their depth, power, and authenticity.
Why This Distinction Matters
You might be wondering: Why does it matter if we call yoga a philosophy instead of a religion? Why not let people use yoga however they want?
Here’s why it matters:
Cultural Appropriation and Erasure
When a religious system is commodified into "just a philosophy," its cultural and spiritual context is erased. It becomes a product, something to be bought and sold. For Hindus and Buddhists, this erasure is deeply painful. Imagine if Christian prayer or Muslim fasting were marketed as "mindfulness hacks" for self-improvement. The disrespect would be obvious, but for Eastern traditions, it often goes unnoticed.Spiritual Bypassing
By treating yoga, meditation, and mindfulness as quick-fix solutions for stress and anxiety, people bypass the deeper work of self-transformation. Yoga is not just physical stretching; it's a path toward enlightenment. Buddhism isn't just life advice; it's a way of ending suffering. When people ignore these deeper aspects, they miss the true power of these systems.Religious Integrity
Calling yoga a "fitness routine" is like calling baptism a "cleansing bath." It reduces something sacred into something shallow. Respecting these systems as religions means acknowledging their wholeness, not just picking out the parts we like.
Reclaiming the Sacred: How We Can Do Better
So, how can we shift our understanding and start honoring these systems for what they are?
Use the Right Language
Instead of calling yoga a "philosophy," call it a spiritual path. Instead of calling mindfulness a "stress-relief technique," recognize it as a core Buddhist practice. Language shapes perception, and using respectful language helps restore dignity to these practices.Acknowledge the Source
If you practice yoga or mindfulness, learn about its origins. Recognize that these aren't "universal wellness tools" — they have roots in Hinduism, Buddhism, and other Eastern systems. If you benefit from these practices, give credit where it's due.Deepen Your Practice
If you engage with yoga or meditation, consider learning about their spiritual dimensions. Study the Eight Limbs of Yoga, not just the asanas. Learn about Buddhist teachings on compassion, suffering, and the Four Noble Truths. Instead of just practicing, connect with the deeper wisdom that these systems offer.Support Indigenous Voices
Follow and support teachers who are rooted in the original traditions of these practices. Many Hindu, Buddhist, and Indigenous teachers are working to reclaim these spiritual systems from Western commodification. Their voices deserve to be heard.
Final Reflections
Yoga is not just a workout. Meditation is not just a "mental health hack." Buddhism is not just "life philosophy." These are religions with deep spiritual meaning, sacred texts, and pathways to liberation.
When the West reduces them to "philosophies," it erases their religious essence. It makes them easier to sell, but it also strips them of their authenticity and power.
The next time you hear someone say, "Yoga is just stretching," or "Buddhism is just philosophy," you’ll know better. These systems deserve to be seen for what they are: sacred, whole, and worthy of reverence.
By honoring the full religious context of Yoga, Buddhism, and other Eastern paths, we can approach them with the respect, gratitude, and depth they deserve. We don't have to "extract" their benefits to appreciate them. We can engage with them in a holistic way — body, mind, and spirit.
If you’ve benefited from these practices, consider taking a step back and asking, How can I honor the traditions that made this possible? The answer may lead you deeper than you ever expected.
What do you think? Have you experienced this shift in perspective? Leave a comment and share your story. Your reflections are always welcome.
